Over the last decade, consumers have grown more concerned about how businesses use personal data. In response, legislators introduced rules to govern the collection and storage of that data. In many jurisdictions, businesses may only collect personal data with the user’s explicit consent.
For WordPress site owners, privacy regulations impose a number of obligations. The most pressing is WordPress cookie consent management. Sites operating under strict privacy laws must implement a cookie consent system that displays a banner and requests permission.
That seems straightforward, but cookie consent poses challenges such as identifying cookies, blocking scripts before consent, and handling caching. In this article, we explore the legal basis for WordPress cookie consent requirements, the challenges that site owners have to overcome, and WordPress plugins and consent management platforms (CMP) that streamline cookie consent management.
A cookie is a small text file that websites store on a user’s device. When you visit a website, it can place cookies in your browser to remember information about your visit. Cookies serve various purposes: they keep you logged in, remember your preferences, and enable shopping carts to function.
However, cookies also play a central role in tracking user behavior across websites. Third-party cookies, in particular, allow advertisers and analytics platforms to build detailed profiles of browsing habits, which is why they require explicit user consent under some data privacy regimes.
The EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) is the most influential privacy law governing cookie consent. It mandates that consent must be specific, informed, freely given, and unambiguous. If you do business in the EU or if your content is accessible to EU citizens, users should be able to:
GDPR penalties can be hugely damaging. To give one recent example, France’s data protection regulator fined Google almost $380 million for failing to enforce proper cookie consent mechanisms.
Beyond the EU, cookie consent laws are more fragmented and less stringent. The U.K. is no longer a member of the EU, but the UK GDPR law imposes broadly similar obligations.
The U.S. has no single cookie law, but there are state-level privacy laws that indirectly address cookie consent. California’s CCPA/CPRA doesn’t mandate prior consent for data collection. However, it does require sites to allow users to opt out of sharing or selling their personal data, which includes sharing with companies that place third-party cookies. In effect, these restrictions make opt-out cookie banners necessary. States such as Colorado, Connecticut, and Virginia have similar or more stringent rules.
Many countries have similar rules focused on getting users’ meaningful consent. Canada’s PIPEDA has an opt-out mechanism that requires meaningful consent. Other countries with consent laws include Brazil and South Africa.
Cookie consent requirements vary, and, as a site owner, it’s your responsibility to check and comply with the relevant data privacy laws. However, we can use the GDPR’s categorization of essential and non-essential cookies to see the basic distinction many cookie laws make.
For consent purposes, cookies are categorized based on their function and impact on user privacy. Strictly necessary cookies do not require explicit user consent. These are cookies used for basic website functionality such as maintaining user sessions, remembering login credentials, and enabling secure transactions.
Non-essential cookies, in contrast, require clear user consent before being deployed. These include analytics cookies that track user behavior and website performance, advertising cookies that create user profiles for targeted marketing, and social media cookies that enable sharing and tracking across platforms.
Functional cookies that enhance user experience but aren’t strictly necessary, such as those remembering language preferences or customization settings, may also require consent.
The biggest cookie consent challenge is understanding which cookies your site sets in user browsers. Out of the box, WordPress sets a small number of cookies, mostly necessary for the site to work. But every plugin can add new cookies. Without a cookie audit, you don’t know which cookies your site uses, which plugins set them, and whether they require consent.
Site owners must block non-essential cookies until after the user gives consent. Technically, that means delaying scripts by default and activating them once consent is given. That’s challenging to do consistently, and as the site and plugins are updated, the number and type of cookies will change.
Cookie banners are not the most user- or conversion-friendly UI element. Web designers would prefer not to confront users with a consent form as soon as they arrive on a site. But, beyond the unavoidable UX issues, consent banners can cause additional technical and performance problems.
Cookie forms are dynamic elements that change based on user interactions and consent status. That can cause cached pages to display consent banners improperly or show outdated consent states, forcing site owners to implement complex cache exclusion rules that can reduce site performance.
Additionally, improperly configured consent systems can block analytics tracking or create data gaps in Google Analytics and similar platforms, making it difficult to accurately measure site performance and user behavior until consent preferences are properly recorded.
Site owners have to deal with multiple jurisdictions with different rules. The inclination is to keep the user experience simple, but in doing so, there’s a risk of failing to comply with stricter cookie regimes.
It is technically possible to “roll your own” cookie consent solution. But it is not advisable. As we outlined in the previous section, cookie consent is hard to get right, and getting it wrong can be disastrous.
One alternative is to block users from regions with strict cookie consent laws. That’s feasible for local businesses or media sites with geographically limited audiences. However, geolocation is not 100% accurate, and even if it were, few site owners want to turn away consumers from the world’s most economically prosperous regions.
For most WordPress site owners, the best option is a third-party cookie consent management solution. These come in two main types. First, WordPress plugins that handle cookie consent entirely on-site. Second, third-party consent management platforms (CMP) that integrate with WordPress, usually via a plugin.
When evaluating cookie management solutions for your website, consider these common features that help ensure privacy compliance and user trust:
One feature worth calling out is compatibility with Google Consent Mode (GCM). Cookie consent systems play havoc with web analytics, often resulting in missing or inaccurate data. GCM ensures that basic interactions can still be tracked without compromising cookie compliance. In the background, it adjusts how Google’s tracking tags behave based on the user’s consent status. That ability depends on support from your cookie management solution.
Let’s look at three WordPress consent management solutions that include all of the features discussed in this section.
WPConsent is a WordPress-native cookie consent plugin. It offers automatic scanning to detect cookies, customizable banner templates, and consent logging stored in your WordPress database for maximum privacy. The plugin includes geolocation detection and automatic script blocking, making it suitable for businesses looking for a self-hosted solution that doesn’t rely on an external SaaS platform.
CookieYes offers a plug-and-play consent management experience with automatic daily cookie scanning and ready-made templates. The plugin supports GDPR, CCPA, and other global privacy laws. Features include geotargeting, multilingual banners in over 30 languages, and integration with Google Consent Mode v2. It’s designed for marketers and business owners who need fast implementation with minimal technical overhead.
Cookiebot CMP is a cloud-based consent management platform that integrates with WordPress through a dedicated plugin. It automatically scans, categorizes, and blocks cookies, supports up to 60 languages, and includes advanced features like Google Consent Mode integration and regular automated scanning to keep cookie policies current.
Pressable’s managed WordPress hosting provides a secure, high-performance foundation for your site. Pressable is an Automattic company, and our hosting platform is built on the same ultra-reliable cloud infrastructure as WordPress.com and WP VIP. Every WordPress hosting plan includes automatic scaling, a global content delivery network, and our easy-to-use control panel.
Discover our full range of WordPress hosting features or schedule a demo to learn more.
The tutorial will focus on setting up CircleCI config.yml file to deploy the master branch of a GitHub repository via SFTP. To follow along with this tutorial you will need: 1. A theme or plugin that you […]
Ready to install a WordPress theme? Great! There are tons of resources online when it comes to themes. We recommend themes from the WordPress.org Theme Directory or a Premium theme from the WordPress.org Premium theme Directory. […]
Editing the WordPress database can feel intimidating, and for good reason. Apart from a few static files, the database stores everything that gives your site its identity: posts, pages, users, settings, and plugin configurations. A […]